Child Labor; Think About It:
Good Morning Middle America; your King of Simple News is on that air.
Alert reader Karen Buley recently commented, “Child labor laws came in due to unions. Is it better for our kids to be indoors watching TV ?” Hold on there just a darn minute Karen. Who could be against child labor laws? Actually… me for one.
Our opinions of child labor have been formed far more from the use of propaganda than from the use of independent thought and research. To make my point, let’s look at a different example of social conditioning.
How many hours should an adult work in a day? At what age should one retire? How much vacation should one receive in a calendar year? If these questions were asked of the majority of our population, the answers would be; eight hours, 65 years old, and three weeks’ vacation per year. But none of those answers are patently true. Custom and indoctrination are a dangerous combination.
So what are the true answers to the above questions? We should work as many hours per day as it takes to maintain our individual acceptable level of happiness; your choice. We should retire at whatever age we plan for and at such point that we can maintain ourselves without imposing on others; live simple, retire early. And, we should take all of the time off possible, while once again, not imposing a hardship on others.
There are few actual laws that control our lives; most are self imposed from a lack of independent thought and individual planning. We tend to follow the herd regardless of where the herd is going.
On the subject of child labor, if it were actually a crime to force kids to work, my folks would have done life without the possibility of parole. As would the parents of nearly every kid that I grew up with.
The children of farm families in the 50’s and 60’s worked long hard hours; of that I can testify under oath. The work provided by the children of our pioneer heritage was integral to the building of America.
Am I bitter today from having to have actually worked as a child? Hardly, I count my greatest personal blessing as that of growing up working on a farm. There may be some things that I can’t do, but right off the bat I really can’t think of any. My childhood work created independence, strength of character, responsibility, a sense of accomplishment, and the stark reality that there is no free lunch.
So what changed? The widely held current belief that “I don’t want my kids to work as hard as I had to,” didn’t occur overnight. Nah, the whole mess materialized over time. Tell a lie, tell a big lie, tell it often, and it will become truth to the masses.
Today our children can no longer find work due to laws that were formed to remove children from the workforce “for their own good.” No more lawns to mow, or crops to tend, or hay to bale, or summer jobs at the factory. These past summer standards of employment have deemed to be too hard, too dangerous, and too dirty for modern children.
The costs associated with wage and hour laws, unemployment insurance, social security withholding, OSHA, liability insurance, Workers Compensation and child labor laws…all prohibit the hiring of kids. And that’s just the way it was planned.
Instead, to earn money the kids go door to door saying such things as, “Our school soccer team is going to Australia and we are collecting donations to pay for the trip.”
At the same time that the kids learned that being excused from the horrendous labor of taking out the trash and lawn mowing, the adults were being indoctrinated into saying, “I don’t want my kids to have to work as hard as I did.” My question is, “Why not?”
Are you a worthless, irresponsible, mentally and physically crippled individual? Or did you grow up to be a productive, responsible, well rounded person?
“Preconceived notions are the locks on the door to wisdom.” ― Merry Browne

I worked from the time I could walk, I was only getting water for the guys on the jobsite or walking around picking up trash, but it was on the jobsite and I was getting paid. I learned the value of money and always took pride in what I earned even as a child.
Then I grew up became a parent and said I will not do that to my kids!!
I was wrong period end of report.
I love my kids dearly but they are so far behind were I was at their age it shocks me. They just don’t get it. They keep telling me I do not get it, I guess we will see.
Not only did we work weekends and summers but we were required to set aside 10% of take home pay for tithes and another 25% for room and board. The 25% went into the family Christmas fund (which occasionally got raided for emergency repairs of essential equipment and or kids.) Early lessons in work, budgeting, and saving are worth more than most college degrees.
Scott and Hutch,
Thank you both for your personal stories.
While I understand that one size does not fit all, a few years ago I realized that many teenagers have never worked all day in their entire lives. What shock a real job must be!
I was born in the late 50s. One grandfather ran a machine shop. My other grandfather was a pig and chicken farmer. I worked in the shop, in the garden, tended to animals, did yard work, vacuumed & mopped floors, took out garbage, you name it. I earned money from the time I was 8 or 9. My Social Security statement goes back to the early 70s!
Today, kids don’t work. Heck, they don’t play either, at least not like we did. They play video games. There are kids in the neighborhood but they never go outside to play. Their parents drive them to soccer or whatever.
I’ve written in the past on this site that large companies now hold the jobs that were once assigned to kids. Lawn care, snow shoveling, extra summer farm labor, extra summer factory labor and so on.
Even if they do want to work, there are precious few jobs for kids. Liability alone in our litigious society has given pause to hiring a teenager.
That said, why is it that most parents expect so little in the way of their kids helping out at home? Playing with cell phones and video games combined with watching TV seems to be the resume for most 18 year old’s. Can that be a good thing?
Of course, I don’t think so. We simply fail to consider the direction that the herd is moving.
Not too sure that I think child labor laws can be blamed for most kids not working.. When my kids grew up, working in a factory wasn’t considered, but the kids always found jobs.. When did it start, that they can’t mow lawns.?? I guess, I never knew that.. But, it always seemed that there were jobs available for any kid willing to do a good job for a decent wage.. I think the key might be a kid willing, and able to do a good job..
wma..
Wma,
National lawn care companies that have workers comp, liability insurance, and that are OSHA complaint have replaced kids.
Please remember that if you hire a teenager and they are injured in any way, shape, or form…all that stands between you and poverty is a good lawyer.
If you pay a teenager (say in California) more than $100 per quarter, you are required to have a federal ID number, make payroll deductions such as unemployment insurance, Social Security, Workers Comp, etc. etc. etc.
Of course, we can break the existing laws and take a chance of losing our homes over a lawn care job; but who is willing to do that?
I’m a single Mom. Just today, my 14 year old daughter went to work with me. She filed, organized, and did whatever I or my assistant needed. She’s done this numerous times before. I pay her myself. She doesn’t receive an allowance because I want her to be responsible for things in our home, and I support her occassional trips to the movies with friends, and other things like that. I want her to understand that life isn’t a free ride. She actually wants to get a job as soon as anyone will hire her. She wants to buy her own car and clothes. I do want her life to be better than mine, but I don’t want to hand it to her. Many kids today are brought up with a sense of entitlement. They couldn’t so much as add gas to a lawn mower. I am thankful that my daughter is learning common sense and the value of earning a dollar. It would be wise for parents to get back to the basics in teaching thier kids.
Growing up on the near north side of Chicago in the middle 40’s I worked from the time I was eight years old. I was self employed… walking the alleys of my neighborhood looking for bottles. Beer bottles were the best because I could return them to a local bar and always found a drunk that would drop a dime my way. Then I hustled delivery’s from a delicatessen for tips. Those were good times.
But that’s old fart talk… times were different then.
If anybody is interested in an explanation of how we got where we are today I recommend the video ‘Generation Zero.’ It paints a pretty vivid picture.
Rob
I fear that most of the younger workers are going to be caught in a low wage pit without a means of escape. It will amount to a lost generation. There were always these kinds of workers, but their numbers are exploding. Another job to forbid your teenager to take is pizza delivery driver. Unless you have an expensive rider on your auto insurance, you can lose your home and nine dimes out of every dollar you will ever make. (You, dad, and your child too.)
Pat,
Your daughter will thank you forever for the experience that you are providing for her.
When it comes to kids working, Simon Legree I’m not. Kids need kid time. I disagree with year around school for instance. As hard as farm work was, there was always a day of fishing or hunting in the near future.
My belief is that there must be balance between work and play. Kids need to understand the connection between work and reward well before they are college grads.
Rob, Thanks for your comments, I love that old fart talk!! I’ll check out generation zero.
geezermom,
I have your same fears in relationship to wages. High unemployment drives down wages and I see high unemployment for several years to come…and perhaps from now on.
We have to remember that not so long ago households operated with one parent in the workplace. Gross employment numbers were very different at that point and time. Today, “normal” employment numbers have nearly doubled as it is difficult to get by without two incomes, a fact that all the single moms and dads can testify to.